YourMoneyWise logo YourMoneyWise

BofA Poll India Least Favored: Smart Investment Strategy

India is now Asia's least favored market per the BofA poll. Here is how retail investors should reposition their SIPs, handle taxes, and avoid panic selling.

BofA Poll Says India Least Favored in Asia: What Should You Do? — illustrative featured image
The Bloomberg terminal at your friendly neighborhood mutual fund distributor probably flashed red on Tuesday morning. The headline, paraphrased for the uninitiated, read something like: India is now the least favored market in Asia, according to the latest BofA fund manager survey. Indonesia, the perennial punching bag of emerging market allocators, got a reprieve. We took the crown. If you have been investing in Indian equities for the last three years, this feels like whiplash. We went from the "bright spot in a dark global economy" to the kid nobody wants on their cricket team. The shift is brutal, but the data is the data. The question is not whether the poll is accurate. The question is whether you, a salaried professional with a SIP and a dream, should care. Let's parse the noise, figure out what the foreign money is actually telling us, and then decide what to do with your own hard-earned rupees. ### Why the Sudden Cold Feet? The BofA poll isn't just a random guess. It is a survey of global fund managers who control trillions in assets. When they say they are "underweight" India, they mean they are holding fewer Indian stocks than the benchmark suggests they should. That is a deliberate, active choice. The reasons are fairly mundane, which is oddly comforting. It isn't a scandal or a policy crisis. It is a valuation problem. - **Expensive is an understatement.** Indian small-caps and mid-caps have been trading at premiums that make little sense on a price-to-earnings basis. When the rest of Asia is offering comparable growth at half the multiple, money moves. - **The earnings reality check.** The Q2 results season was a dud. FMCG companies saw rural demand stall. IT services firms are still waiting for the US client budgets to open up. The "India growth story" is intact, but the quarterly delivery is lagging the hype. - **The China pivot.** It sounds counterintuitive, but Chinese equities are suddenly cheap enough that global funds are dipping their toes back in. When the world's second largest economy sneezes, money flows out of the periphery (us) and into the "value" trade (them). The poll result is essentially a snapshot of this sentiment. It is a rearview mirror, not a GPS. ### The Retail Investor Reality Check Here is where we need to separate the macro from the micro. The BofA poll is about *foreign* institutional flows. These guys are fair-weather friends. They have a mandate to chase global alpha, and they will dump a perfectly good company just to rotate into a cheaper one across the border. You are not a global macro fund. You have a salary, a Provident Fund, and a monthly SIP that hits your account on the 1st of the month. Your investment horizon is not the next quarter; it is the next decade. However, ignoring the poll entirely would be foolish. There is a reason the smart money is cautious. The risk of a flat market for the next 18 months is real. When FIIs are selling, the index tends to stagnate even if the economy is growing. This is a liquidity issue, not a fundamental one. So, what is a retail investor to do? You cannot just sit in cash because the market might go sideways. Inflation will eat you alive. But you also shouldn't be aggressively buying the dip with leverage. ### Our Take: What We Recommend Let's get specific. We are not going to tell you to "stay the course" and leave it at that. That is lazy advice. Here is how we would position a portfolio if we were sitting in your chair today, assuming you have a 5 to 10 year horizon. **1. Shift the SIP allocation toward Large Caps.** The pain in the BofA poll is mostly concentrated in the broader market. Large caps (Nifty 50) are relatively less frothy. If you are currently investing 50% in mid-cap funds, trim that to 30% and put the extra 20% into a Nifty 50 Index Fund. Think UTI Nifty 50 or HDFC Index Fund. The valuation gap between large and mid is too wide right now. **2. Look at the "Owned by the Government" trade.** PSU stocks have had a massive run, but the recent correction has brought some sanity back. More importantly, the government's capex cycle is the one engine that is definitely running. We like the idea of holding a focused PSU or infrastructure fund, but keep this to a satellite position, no more than 10% of your equity portfolio. **3. Consider the "Internal Consumption" hedge.** The BofA guys are selling India because they want liquidity. But domestic mutual funds are still receiving record inflows. This is a tug of war. To play this, look at private sector banks and select NBFCs. They are the direct beneficiaries of domestic savings. A fund like Mirae Asset Large Cap or a focused banking fund via an ETF (like Bank BeES) gives you exposure to the local money flow that is countering the FII outflow. **4. Do not touch Small Caps right now.** We know. They are down 15% from the peak. It is tempting to average down. Resist the urge. The small-cap index is still expensive on a historical basis. Wait for the BofA sentiment to turn before you go bargain hunting in that segment. You will have plenty of time to buy later. ### The Tax Angle You Cannot Ignore Since this is YourMoneyWise, we have to talk about the taxman. If you are rebalancing out of mid-caps and into large-caps, you are triggering capital gains. - **Equity Funds:** If you have held your mid-cap fund for more than 12 months, the gains are Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG). You pay 10% on gains exceeding Rs 1 lakh. If you are sitting on a 30% profit, paying 10% tax to move into a safer asset is a reasonable price for risk reduction. - **The Rs 1 Lakh exemption:** Plan your redemptions so that your total LTCG across all equity funds stays under this threshold in a financial year. If you have to sell more, consider splitting the redemption across two financial years (sell half in March, half in April) to utilize the exemption twice. Do not let the tax tail wag the investment dog, but do not ignore it either. A 10% tax hit is cheaper than a 20% drawdown next year. ### The Psychological Play The hardest part of this poll is the mental game. For three years, we got used to seeing our portfolios go up every single month. The last six months have been choppy. The BofA poll is just confirming what your portfolio statement already told you: we are in a consolidation phase. This is where the discipline of the SIP matters. When the market is flat, your SIP buys more units. When the market eventually turns, you own more shares. The BofA poll is a lagging indicator. By the time the FIIs decide India is "cheap" again, the rally will already be underway. The worst thing you can do right now is stop your SIPs. That converts a temporary paper loss into a permanent opportunity cost. The second worst thing you can do is panic and move everything to debt funds, locking in the low equity prices. Stay invested, but tilt toward quality. The BofA survey is a warning, not a death sentence. It is telling you that the easy money has been made. The next phase requires patience, not aggression. ### FAQ **1. Should I stop my SIPs because FIIs are selling India?** No. In fact, a flat or falling market is the best time to continue SIPs. You are buying at lower average costs. Stopping the SIP to avoid short-term losses is the classic mistake of selling low and buying high. Keep the SIP running, but review the *funds* you are investing in. If you are heavy in small-caps, switch the SIP to a large-cap or flexi-cap fund. **2. Is this a good time to buy the dip in Indian stocks?** Only if you are buying quality large caps. The "dip" is not uniform. The Nifty 50 is down modestly, while small-caps have corrected sharply. We advise against catching the falling knife in the broader market. Instead, deploy any lump sum money in tranches over the next 3 to 4 months into a large-cap index fund. This averages out the volatility. **3. How long will this underperformance last?** Historically, these valuation-driven corrections in India last between 12 and 18 months. It will take at least two solid quarters of earnings growth to convince the BofA crowd to come back. Expect sideways movement for the next two quarters. This is a time to accumulate, not to expect fireworks.

Frequently asked questions

1. Should I stop my SIPs because FIIs are selling India?

No. In fact, a flat or falling market is the best time to continue SIPs. You are buying at lower average costs. Stopping the SIP to avoid short-term losses is the classic mistake of selling low and buying high. Keep the SIP running, but review the *funds* you are investing in. If you are heavy in small-caps, switch the SIP to a large-cap or flexi-cap fund.

2. Is this a good time to buy the dip in Indian stocks?

Only if you are buying quality large caps. The "dip" is not uniform. The Nifty 50 is down modestly, while small-caps have corrected sharply. We advise against catching the falling knife in the broader market. Instead, deploy any lump sum money in tranches over the next 3 to 4 months into a large-cap index fund. This averages out the volatility.

3. How long will this underperformance last?

Historically, these valuation-driven corrections in India last between 12 and 18 months. It will take at least two solid quarters of earnings growth to convince the BofA crowd to come back. Expect sideways movement for the next two quarters. This is a time to accumulate, not to expect fireworks.

Why the Sudden Cold Feet?

The BofA poll isn't just a random guess. It is a survey of global fund managers who control trillions in assets. When they say they are "underweight" India, they mean they are holding fewer Indian stocks than the benchmark suggests they should. That is a deliberate, active choice.

Related articles