India vs Indonesia Stocks: Why Investors Are Picking Sides

Why global funds now favor Indonesia over India, what BofA's latest poll means for your SIPs, and how to position your portfolio for 2025 without panic selling.

The last time foreign fund managers had this little love for Indian stocks, Sensex was crawling toward 60,000 and everyone was still arguing about whether work-from-home was here to stay. That was early 2023. Now, in the middle of 2025, the mood has soured again, but here is the twist: the money is not leaving Asia. It is just moving next door. A recent Bank of America survey of global fund managers found that India has overtaken Indonesia as Asia’s least-favored market. Yes, India. The country that was the poster child of emerging market investing just a couple of years ago now ranks below a nation whose stock market is a fraction of our size. If you are a salaried investor who has been quietly adding to your mutual fund SIPs, this matters more than you think. Let us unpack what is happening, why it is happening, and what it means for your portfolio. ## The Great Sentiment Flip Let us get one thing straight. Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) are not rational long-term owners. They are renters. They lease your market for a quarter, maybe two, and they move out when the maintenance charges go up. Right now, the maintenance charges in India have gone up. Corporate earnings growth, which was running at a blistering 20 percent plus for two years, has decelerated to high single digits. Valuations, meanwhile, are still priced for a world where every Indian company grows at compound annual rates forever. The Nifty trades at around 20 times forward earnings. Indonesia trades at closer to 13 times. When a fund manager in New York or London looks at that gap, the math does not require a PhD. What the BofA poll reveals is not just a preference for Indonesia. It reveals a broader fatigue with the Indian growth story at the margin. The survey shows global investors are underweight India more than any other Asian market. They are overweight China (on valuation support), overweight Japan (on corporate reforms), and selectively buying Southeast Asia. Indonesia, with its commodity exports, domestic consumption story, and cheaper entry point, is the beneficiary of the "India is too expensive" trade. ## Why Indonesia, Specifically? Indonesia is not a perfect market. It has governance issues, a history of resource nationalism, and a stock market that is heavily weighted toward banks and consumer staples. But it also has what India lacks right now: a fresh narrative. Here are three concrete reasons fund managers are rotating: 1. **Valuation headroom.** The Jakarta Composite Index trades at a meaningful discount to Indian benchmarks. For a fund manager whose mandate is "emerging market equities," buying India at 20 times earnings when Indonesia is at 13 times is a hard sell to their risk committee. 2. **Commodity and downstream story.** Indonesia is the world’s largest nickel producer and a major player in palm oil, coal, and now EV battery materials. Global supply chain diversification away from China has made Indonesian resources strategically important. India, by contrast, is a net importer of energy and many raw materials. 3. **Domestic reform momentum.** The new government under Prabowo Subianto has pushed through bureaucratic simplifications and is courting foreign direct investment aggressively. The "China plus one" manufacturing shift is landing in Vietnam and Indonesia more than in India for electronics and assembly work. None of this means Indonesia will outperform India over the next decade. It means that at the margin, the smart money sees better risk-reward there today. ## What This Means for Your SIP Here is where we need to separate the noise from the signal. The BofA poll is a sentiment snapshot, not a verdict on Indian equities. But sentiment drives flows, and flows drive near-term returns. For the Indian salaried investor, the practical implications are these: - **Your Nifty SIP will likely see lower returns over the next 12 to 18 months** compared to the last three years. That is not a forecast of doom. It is a base rate adjustment. - **Large caps will lag mid and small caps** in the near term, because FIIs predominantly own large caps. Domestic institutional investors (DIIs) have been net buyers, but they cannot single-handedly push a 20-times earnings market higher forever. - **Sector rotation matters.** Foreign money leaving India is not leaving every sector equally. IT services, which earn in dollars, become relatively attractive when the rupee weakens. Banks with strong deposit franchises remain domestic darlings. The biggest mistake you can make right now is to stop your SIPs because a survey says India is unpopular. That is [timing the market with a blunt instrument](/finance/blog/a-beginner-s-guide-to-buying-stocks-on-a-dip-lessons-from-the-recent-market-fall). The second biggest mistake is to ignore the signal entirely and assume Indian exceptionalism overrides all valuation logic. ## The Currency Angle Nobody Talks About When we discuss India vs Indonesia stocks, we usually focus on index levels and price-to-earnings ratios. But for a foreign investor, the local currency return is half the story. The rupee has been drifting lower against the dollar for years, roughly 2 to 3 percent annually. The Indonesian rupiah has been more volatile, but it has also had periods of sharp appreciation when commodity prices rally. If you are an Indian investor looking at Indonesia as a diversification play, you are taking on currency risk in both directions. Your returns in rupee terms will depend on the rupiah-dollar-rupee triangle. That is not a simple bet. For most salaried investors, buying a global fund that includes Indonesia within a broader emerging market mandate is safer than trying to pick Jakarta stocks directly. ## Our Take: What We Recommend We are not going to tell you to abandon India. That would be foolish. The structural story of a young population, rising incomes, and formalization of the economy remains intact. But we are going to tell you that the next two years will test your patience. Here is what we would do with fresh money today: - **Keep your core Indian allocation, but tilt toward quality.** If you are investing in a large-cap fund, check its top holdings. Are they paying reasonable prices for growth, or are they holding the same expensive names from 2023? Funds like Parag Parikh Flexi Cap or UTI Nifty 200 Quality 50 Index offer better downside protection than plain vanilla index funds in a de-rating phase. - **Add a small emerging market or Asia ex-Japan fund allocation.** This is not about chasing Indonesia. It is about not having all your equity chips on one country. A fund like the ICICI Prudential Global Equity FOF or a direct emerging market ETF gives you exposure to Indonesia, Vietnam, and Taiwan without the hassle of opening a foreign brokerage account. - **Do not buy the dip blindly.** The Nifty can fall another 10 percent from here if earnings downgrades continue. Average in with monthly purchases rather than deploying a lump sum. As a beginner, it helps to [learn how to read stock recommendations](/finance/blog/how-to-read-stock-recommendations-from-analysts-like-jefferies-a-beginner-s-play) to separate noise from actionable signals. - **Watch the dollar index.** If the US dollar strengthens further, emerging markets including India and Indonesia will both bleed. If the dollar weakens, the rotation back into India will be swift. Set a reminder to check the DXY once a month. That single number tells you more about [FII flows](/finance/blog/fed-decisions-and-your-mutual-funds-what-indian-investors-should-know) than any analyst commentary. The uncomfortable truth is that India has been the most crowded trade in emerging markets for three years. Crowded trades do not go up forever. They go sideways, or they correct, until the crowd finds something else. Right now, the crowd has found Indonesia. ## What Could Bring Foreign Investors Back It is not all grim. Foreign investor sentiment India is cyclical, and the cycle will turn. Here are three triggers that would reverse the outflows: 1. **Earnings revival.** If the June quarter results show a return to 15 percent plus profit growth, the valuation math becomes defensible again. Domestic consumption, government capex, and a normal monsoon could do it. 2. **A credible fiscal consolidation path.** Global funds hate uncertainty. If the government signals a clear reduction in the fiscal deficit without slashing growth spending, the risk premium on Indian assets will shrink. 3. **Global rate cuts.** When the US Federal Reserve cuts rates, money flows back to emerging markets broadly. India, being the largest and most liquid EM outside China, tends to get the first allocation. Until one of these triggers fires, expect the underweight stance to persist. That does not mean sell everything. It means lower your return expectations, keep your costs low, and remember that surveys like the BofA poll are contrarian indicators at extremes. When India is the least-favored market in Asia, the odds of a positive surprise over the next three years are actually quite good. ## FAQ ### Should I stop my SIP in Indian equity funds because foreign investors are selling? No. SIPs work best when you buy through downcycles. Foreign selling creates lower entry points. What you should do is review your fund's quality and ensure you are not overpaying for a fund that only performed well because the entire market was rising. ### Can I invest directly in Indonesian stocks from India? Technically yes, through international brokerage platforms that allow trading on the Jakarta Stock Exchange. Practically, it is complicated. You face currency conversion, higher brokerage fees, and limited research coverage. A better route is an emerging market mutual fund or ETF that holds Indonesian equities as part of a diversified portfolio. ### How long will this phase of foreign outflows last? Historically, EM sentiment cycles last 6 to 18 months. The current India underweight has been building since late 2024. If earnings recover by the second half of 2025, the rotation could reverse sooner. If global growth slows further, it could extend into 2026. The key is to not try to predict the exact turning point and instead stay invested with a time horizon of five years or more.

India vs Indonesia Stocks: Why Investors Are Picking Sides

Frequently asked questions

Related articles